Are Babe Ruth and Carlos Gonzalez seriously in the same type of linear?

Carlos Gonzalez comparatively shows wide stride in spite of his being a recent player. So applying the linear-or-rotational method, he should be classified as a linear type. 

To change the subject, almost all the old homerun hitters had used to do the wide stride and large weight shift. So they generally have been classified as linear type. (Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron, Willie Mays etc.)

However, in those days, there should be no hitters who had shown the swing such as Gonzalez's it. Then, what brought about that difference? Yes, the theory that can solve this question is the "puncher-or-swinger method", which I advocate.